Bethel By The Sea Homes for Sale

Bethel By The Sea Homes for Sale

Welcome to Bethel By The Sea, a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque city of Vero Beach, Florida. This charming subdivision offers an idyllic coastal lifestyle, where the sun-kissed shores of the Atlantic Ocean are just a stone's throw away. Located in Indian River County, Bethel By The Sea is the perfect blend of tranquility and convenience, making it an ideal choice for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a serene escape.

As you explore this delightful community, you'll find an array of beautifully designed homes for sale, each exuding its own unique charm. From modern coastal cottages to elegant single-family residences, the properties in Bethel By The Sea cater to various tastes and preferences. Many homes feature open floor plans, spacious backyards, and stunning views, allowing residents to bask in the natural beauty that surrounds them. With a strong sense of community and friendly neighbors, you'll feel right at home from the moment you arrive.

Beyond the stunning homes, Bethel By The Sea is conveniently located near an array of amenities. Enjoy easy access to local shops, fine dining, and recreational opportunities, including golf courses, parks, and pristine beaches. The vibrant cultural scene in Vero Beach, with its art galleries and theaters, is just a short drive away, ensuring there's always something to do.

Whether you’re looking for a permanent residence or a vacation getaway, Bethel By The Sea offers the perfect setting to embrace the laid-back Florida lifestyle. Discover your dream home in this enchanting community today!

Newest Bethel By The Sea Homes for Sale

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 297717 MLS

This must be just like living in paradise! Exceptional & practically new 2023 concrete block home in Vero's Central Beach! Featuring impact windows, screened pool w/ outdoor living space, open living w/ custom Quartz built-in, entertaining kitchen w/ island, ample garage space! Bring the golf cart! Located amongst the desirable "flower & tree" streets, 425 HOLLY is nearby to stunning beaches, boutique shopping & dining on Ocean Drive, the Treasure Coast's largest cultural arts facility- the VBMA & Riverside Theatre for musicals, plays & comedy night! Info/sizes subject to error; Buyer verify.

425 Holly Road, Vero Beach

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 297573 MLS

Stunning Mid-Century home in Central Beach! Interior renovation completed by Della Porta in 2017. Recent exterior enhancements include new roof, gutters, custom perimeter fence, landscape/landscape lighting, screened in patios & paver sidewalk. Ideally situated on over 1/4 acre this oak canopied home is steps from the ocean. The open floor plan, island kitchen, new S/S appliances, custom cabinets, granite countertops, coquina fireplace, beamed ceilings & exposed ventilation are just a few of the tasteful upgrades! 3rd bedroom can be office/den. This special home is one of a kind!

3915 Mockingbird Drive, Vero Beach

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 295839 MLS

The Central Beach house you didn't think existed: 2,053/SF, soaring tray ceilings, a grotto pool, newer kitchen, updated plumbing/electrical + 2 renovated full baths + a rare powder room + inside laundry! Uber private E-W lot w/59' ft to E for gardens, casita/guest house! Car-optional livings, steps to beach + all things Vero. No HOA. Sellers looked at 40 homes —all small rooms, low ceilings, laundry in the garage. This is the one! 2026 new flat roof! Your seaside respite or savvy investment property with strong rental history! Elegant + a cut above for discerning buyers!Inspected pre-listing!

400 Live Oak Road, Vero Beach

4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 295844 MLS

Introducing a rare pre-construction opportunity in coveted Central Beach, where refined coastal design meets an unbeatable location. This 4/4.5 home offers effortless beachside living just a short stroll to the ocean, dining & boutiques of Ocean Dr. Inside, a light, charming interior features a dramatic great room w/inverted hip ceilings & a custom entertaining bar w/beverage refrigerator & built-in shelving. The primary suite offers a spa-like bath w/white oak cabinetry. Outdoors, enjoy a private backyard w/ pool, summer kitchen, covered patio, & a sweeping scored concrete driveway.

554 Conn Way, Vero Beach

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 295796 MLS

A must see! This Central Beach pool home was custom-built in 2022. Split plan: 3BR/3.5BA plus a separate office/den. Open-concept design, center island gourmet kitchen overlooking the great room. High ceilings, designer finishes throughout. Private primary suite w/ a gracious bath & 2 walk-in closets, opens to pool. 2 guestrooms w/ private baths. Laundry/mud room, 3 car garage. Private fenced back yard w/ lush landscape surrounding property. Beautiful street & setting. Everything built to highest specifications & priced to sell! Steps to beach access & dining. Sizes are approx/subj to error.

325 Holly Road, Vero Beach

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 295594 MLS

Just steps from the ocean, this Central Beach home is ideally located east of A1A & only a block from the beach in Vero Beach. This two story 3 bedroom, 2 bath property sits on a rare 0.36 acre lot with a fenced yard, spa, and paver patio for outdoor living. Interior features include plantation shutters, a kitchen with an island and breakfast bar, a Florida room, and two laundry rooms including an additional upstairs laundry. Additional highlights include a 1 car garage, security system, buried propane tank, 2021 metal roof, generator, & no HOA near Ocean Drive, beaches, shopping, and dining.

715 Conn Way, Vero Beach

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 293775 MLS

Thoughtfully reimagined in 2021, this furnished 3 bed, 2 bath coastal residence is positioned on a 0.31 acre corner lot in Vero Beach’s sought after Central Beach. Elevated finishes include a metal roof, impact windows, vaulted ceilings, Shiplap detail, crown molding, tile flooring, & California closets. The light filled kitchen features a generous island, wine cooler, propane gas range, and refined entertaining flow. Enjoy a gas fireplace, integrated surround sound, EV charging station, & private outdoor space ideal for relaxed coastal living, all just moments from the beach. Roof & A/C 2019.

506 Conn Way, Vero Beach

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 293095 MLS

Panoramic wide water and sunset views overlooking Bethel Creek in Vero's sought-after central beach! Deep water boater's delight- seawall, private dock, ramp, direct Intracoastal access. +/- .44 acre lot 2 blocks from beach. Sparkling pool. Bright eat-in kitchen features walk-in pantry and lots of work space. Split plan 3 bedrooms with private guest wing + laundry, storage and office. Generous room sizes. Newer metal roof. Detached garage houses an air conditioned game room or could be a 4 car garage. Attractive brick driveway, lush landscaping, lighting and more. Dimensions are approximate.

635 Live Oak Road, Vero Beach

Start Your Search

Jason Coley

Meet Jason Michael Coley Team Leader | Real Estate Veteran | World Explorer (with Wi-Fi) With over 20 years in the real estate game, Jason Coley isn’t just a Realtor—he’s the driving force behind a top-producing team that dominates the Treasure Coast market. He leads a powerhouse crew of professionals who know how to hustle, deliver results, and have a little fun doing it. Jason’s been buying, selling, negotiating, and navigating the ever-changing world of real estate since before smartphones were a thing. He’s the kind of guy who can close a deal in the morning and crack a dad joke in the afternoon—and still leave both clients and teammates smiling. Working side-by-side with his wife Renee for over two decades, the two make an unstoppable team. Whether they’re helping first-time buyers, seasoned investors, or families making a move, they bring experience, strategy, and a whole lot of heart to the table. When they’re not helping clients, Jason and Renee are off cruising the open seas or exploring new corners of the globe—because life’s too short to stay in one place (unless it’s your dream home, of course). Real estate is the business. But people? That’s the passion.

Learn More